Natural gas and diesel generators are both widely used for commercial, industrial and critical-power applications. The better choice depends on the facility, required generator capacity, fuel infrastructure, expected operating profile, permitting requirements and project goals.
Rather than assuming one fuel type is always less expensive, more reliable or better suited to backup power, compare the generator as part of the complete facility power system.
CI Group supplies commercial and industrial generators across a wide range of capacities, manufacturers and configurations, including diesel and natural-gas equipment when available.
Natural Gas vs. Diesel Generators: What’s the Difference?
The most obvious difference is the fuel, but the engine technology is also different.
Diesel generator sets generally use compression-ignition engines. Fuel is injected into highly compressed air, where the heat created by compression causes ignition.
Natural-gas generator sets generally use spark-ignition engines, where a spark initiates combustion of the fuel-air mixture.
The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency regulates stationary compression-ignition and spark-ignition engines under separate New Source Performance Standards, along with other applicable stationary-engine requirements.
Review EPA guidance for stationary engine requirements.
Natural Gas Generator Advantages and Considerations
A natural-gas generator can be an attractive option when the site has an appropriate gas supply and the generator configuration fits the facility’s required load and operating profile.
Potential Advantages of Natural Gas Generators
- Pipeline fuel supply: Where adequate utility gas service is available, the facility may not need to maintain a large onsite liquid-fuel inventory.
- No routine diesel-fuel storage: Pipeline-supplied systems avoid many of the storage, fuel-quality and refueling considerations associated with onsite diesel tanks.
- Lower combustion CO₂ per unit of fuel energy: U.S. Energy Information Administration data shows that natural gas produces less carbon dioxide per million Btu when burned than distillate fuel oil, which includes diesel.
- Available for a wide range of applications: Natural-gas generator sets are available for commercial, industrial and other stationary-power applications.
View EIA carbon dioxide emissions coefficients by fuel.
Natural Gas Generator Considerations
- The site needs an adequate natural-gas supply and pressure for the generator being considered.
- Generator sizing needs to account for the actual facility load and intended operating rating.
- Gas piping, meter capacity and utility coordination can affect installation scope.
- The project’s emergency plan should consider whether pipeline fuel availability meets the facility’s required backup-power strategy.
- Emissions and permitting requirements still apply and vary by engine, location and application.
A natural-gas connection therefore should not be evaluated only on whether gas service exists at the property. The project team needs to verify that the available supply can support the generator under the required operating conditions.
Diesel Generator Advantages and Considerations
Diesel generators are extensively used for commercial and industrial standby-power applications and are available across a broad range of capacities.
Potential Advantages of Diesel Generators
- Onsite fuel supply: A properly designed fuel system gives the facility a defined quantity of fuel available at the site.
- Broad equipment availability: Diesel generators are available across a wide range of commercial and industrial capacities.
- Well-established standby application: Diesel generator sets are commonly used in facilities that require emergency or standby generation.
- Fuel reserve can be planned: Tank capacity, estimated generator consumption and refueling strategy can be used to plan around a desired operating period.
Diesel Generator Considerations
- Fuel has to be stored, monitored and maintained appropriately.
- Available runtime is affected by usable tank capacity and generator fuel consumption.
- Extended operation may require a refueling strategy.
- Tanks and associated fuel-system equipment add to the installation requirements.
- Applicable emissions and permitting requirements need to be addressed before equipment selection is finalized.
For facilities evaluating diesel runtime, CI Group’s Diesel Generator Fuel Consumption Chart provides general planning estimates at different generator capacities and load levels.
Fuel Availability: Onsite Storage vs. Pipeline Supply
Fuel strategy is one of the most important distinctions between natural-gas and diesel standby systems.
A diesel system typically uses fuel stored at the facility. This gives the site a measurable onsite fuel reserve, but the facility also becomes responsible for fuel storage, condition, tank maintenance and arrangements for additional fuel if operation continues beyond the available supply.
A pipeline natural-gas system can operate without a large onsite liquid-fuel tank, but it depends on an adequate gas supply reaching the facility.
Neither arrangement is automatically better for every application.
The facility should evaluate:
- Required generator operating duration
- Available natural-gas infrastructure
- Required gas pressure and flow
- Available diesel-storage capacity
- Fuel-delivery access
- Emergency refueling arrangements
- Local utility and emergency-planning considerations
Which Generator Is Less Expensive?
There is no reliable universal rule that says natural-gas generators always cost more to purchase or diesel generators always cost more to operate.
The actual project cost depends on factors such as:
- Generator capacity
- Manufacturer and model
- New, surplus or pre-owned condition
- Engine and alternator configuration
- Required enclosure
- Controls and switchgear
- Existing fuel infrastructure
- Fuel tanks or gas-piping requirements
- Site preparation
- Freight and rigging
- Installation
- Permitting
- Local fuel prices
- Expected operating hours
- Maintenance requirements
The appropriate comparison is therefore the total installed and operating cost for the specific application, not a blanket assumption about one fuel.
Facilities also comparing equipment condition can review Used vs. New Generators: Cost & Buying Guide.
Compare Fuel Cost Based on Expected Use
Fuel price alone does not determine the operating cost of a generator.
The calculation should consider:
- Generator fuel-consumption rate
- Expected load
- Expected annual operating hours
- Local diesel or natural-gas pricing
- Fuel delivery or utility charges
- Maintenance requirements
For a standby generator that operates primarily during testing and occasional utility outages, fuel economics may have a different impact on the overall project than they would for equipment expected to operate frequently.
Natural Gas vs. Diesel Generator Emissions
Emissions comparisons need to be made carefully.
According to the U.S. Energy Information Administration, natural gas produces less carbon dioxide when combusted per unit of fuel energy than distillate fuel oil. EIA currently lists natural gas at approximately 116.65 pounds of CO₂ per million Btu compared with approximately 163.45 pounds per million Btu for distillate fuel oil.
That does not mean every natural-gas generator automatically has lower emissions for every regulated pollutant or operating condition.
Actual generator emissions depend on:
- Engine design
- Generator efficiency
- Operating load
- Emissions-control equipment
- Fuel composition
- Operating hours
- Applicable federal, state and local requirements
EPA regulates stationary diesel compression-ignition engines and natural-gas spark-ignition engines under different standards, and project requirements can vary by engine age, size, application and location.
Review EPA stationary-engine compliance requirements.
What About Generator Footprint?
The physical footprint of a generator should be compared using the actual equipment being considered rather than assuming one fuel type is always larger.
Required space can be affected by:
- Generator capacity
- Engine configuration
- Enclosure
- Radiator and cooling design
- Exhaust equipment
- Diesel fuel tank configuration
- Natural-gas piping and regulators
- Required maintenance clearances
For sites with limited space, review the complete installed arrangement rather than only the generator-set dimensions.
Do Diesel Generators Start Faster?
Start and transfer performance should be evaluated using the specifications of the actual generator, controls and transfer system.
It is not accurate to assume that every diesel generator reaches acceptable power faster than every natural-gas generator.
The complete emergency-power sequence can be affected by:
- Engine and generator design
- Starting system
- Ambient conditions
- Generator controls
- Automatic transfer-switch settings
- Required voltage and frequency stabilization
- Load sequencing
If a facility has a specific maximum transfer-time requirement, the equipment should be selected and configured around that requirement.
Maintenance Requirements Apply to Both Fuel Types
Natural-gas and diesel generator systems both require planned maintenance and periodic testing.
Pacific Northwest National Laboratory notes that standby-generator O&M cost varies based on generator size, operating profile, fuel type and maintenance plan. Its guidance recommends preventative and predictive maintenance based on the equipment and manufacturer requirements.
Review PNNL standby generator maintenance guidance.
Typical maintenance considerations can include:
- Engine fluids and filters
- Cooling system
- Starting batteries
- Fuel system
- Air intake
- Exhaust system
- Controls and alarms
- Generator-end inspection
- Operational testing
- Automatic transfer-switch testing
Diesel systems also require attention to stored fuel condition, while natural-gas systems require appropriate inspection and maintenance of their gas-supply components.
Generator Rating Still Matters
Fuel type does not replace the need to select the correct generator rating.
Generators can be rated for different operating profiles, including standby, prime and continuous applications.
When comparing natural-gas and diesel equipment, confirm that both units are being evaluated using a rating appropriate for the intended application rather than comparing two kW numbers that represent different operating conditions.
Don’t Forget the Automatic Transfer Switch
Whether the generator uses diesel or natural gas, it still needs to integrate with the facility’s electrical distribution and transfer equipment.
An automatic transfer switch can monitor the normal and alternate power sources and coordinate transfer of designated loads according to the system design.
Generator capacity, ATS capacity, voltage, controls and sequence of operation should be evaluated together.
Codes and Standards Apply to the Complete System
Emergency and standby generator installations may be subject to electrical, fire, building, fuel, environmental and other requirements depending on the facility and jurisdiction.
The current 2025 edition of NFPA 110, Standard for Emergency and Standby Power Systems, addresses emergency and standby power sources along with transfer equipment, controls and related auxiliary systems.
The project team should confirm the requirements that apply with the engineer and authority having jurisdiction.
Natural Gas vs. Diesel Generator Comparison
| Consideration | Natural Gas | Diesel |
|---|---|---|
| Fuel Supply | Often supplied through the utility gas system. | Typically stored onsite in a tank. |
| Onsite Fuel Storage | Large liquid-fuel storage may not be required when pipeline gas is used. | Requires an appropriately designed fuel-storage and delivery system. |
| Runtime Planning | Depends on continued availability and capacity of the gas supply. | Can be estimated from usable onsite fuel capacity, generator load and fuel-consumption rate. |
| Equipment Availability | Available across a range of commercial and industrial capacities. | Widely available across commercial, industrial and large standby capacities. |
| CO₂ From Combustion | Lower per unit of fuel energy according to EIA combustion coefficients. | Higher per unit of fuel energy than natural gas according to EIA combustion coefficients. |
| Installation | May require gas-service, piping, regulator and meter evaluation. | May require fuel tanks, containment and fuel-delivery infrastructure. |
| Maintenance | Requires engine, starting, cooling, electrical and fuel-system maintenance. | Requires similar generator maintenance plus management of stored diesel fuel. |
| Permitting | Subject to applicable stationary spark-ignition engine and local requirements. | Subject to applicable stationary compression-ignition engine and local requirements. |
Which Generator Is Better for Backup Power?
Neither natural gas nor diesel is automatically the better generator fuel for every facility.
A diesel system may fit a project that places a high priority on maintaining a defined onsite fuel reserve. A natural-gas system may fit a facility that has adequate gas infrastructure and prefers a pipeline fuel supply rather than maintaining a large liquid-fuel inventory.
The decision should be made by comparing:
- Required generator capacity
- Expected operating profile
- Available fuel infrastructure
- Required runtime
- Onsite storage requirements
- Equipment availability
- Electrical configuration
- Project cost
- Maintenance requirements
- Emissions and permitting
- Physical installation
- Applicable codes and facility requirements
Once those requirements are established, available natural-gas and diesel generators can be compared against the same project criteria.
Compare Generator Options With CI Group
CI Group sources commercial and industrial generator equipment for data centers, commercial buildings, industrial facilities and other critical-power applications.
Available inventory can include new, surplus and pre-owned generator sets across a broad range of capacities and manufacturers.
Evaluating Natural Gas or Diesel Generator Options?
Talk with CI Group about your required capacity, voltage, fuel preference, application and project schedule. We can help identify available generator equipment that matches the requirements of your facility.

